Visit Our CDI Partners

Landslides likely in 2026 Eclipse Award races

Sovereignty wins the Breeders' Cup Classic (G1) at Keeneland.

Sovereignty wins the Breeders' Cup Classic (G1) at Keeneland. (Photo by Horsephotos.com)

When it's time for the electorate to cast their votes for the 2026 Eclipse Awards beginning in late December, there seemingly won’t be many questions about who will win in the flat champion categories. Rather, it will be by how much they win by. 

Indeed, the occurrence of so-called “rogue votes” should be greatly lessened this year, given the results of last weekend’s Breeders’ Cup races.

Although there can be a reasonable debate over who was better between two-year-old colts Hughes and U. S. S. Valor, the depth of Hughes’ accomplishments was bolstered by his win in the Juvenile (G1) on Friday. Earlier on the card, Emphatic capped her own unbeaten season with a strong win in the Juvenile Fillies (G1) to claim her division title.

One bit of trivia to note about Emphatic is she will be the first winner of the Sorority S. at Monmouth Park to be named champion juvenile filly since Dearly Precious in 1975, when it was a Grade 1 contested over six furlongs.

The three-year-old male title was essentially conceded to Golden Tempo early last week when Further Ado opted for the Dirt Mile (G1), which he won in a thriller, instead of the Classic (G1). Golden Tempo made zero impact in the Classic, when finishing sixth of seven, but that did little to detract from his earlier wins in the Kentucky Derby (G1), Belmont (G1), and Lecomte (G3).

The three-year-old filly title, likewise, was probably decided in advance, when Counting Stars was put away for the year after finishing second in the Spinster (G1). Before that, she had accounted for the Coaching Club American Oaks (G1), Acorn (G1), and Fantasy (G2), with additional placings in the Alabama (G1), Kentucky Oaks (G1), and Honeybee (G3). 

The turf specialist Tam Tam might get a boost of support if she wins the American Oaks (G1) in late December, to go along with recent scores in the Del Mar Oaks (G1) and Queen Elizabeth II Challenge Cup (G1). But this category historically recognizes excellence on dirt, even in 2019 when voters went outside the box to recognize the sprint specialist Covfefe.

Sovereignty clinched the older male dirt title in the Breeders’ Cup Classic (G1) over main rivals Forever Young and Knightsbridge, while Nitrogen earned her older dirt female title in the Distaff (G1), defeating Fully Subscribed for the second time this season.

Loading tweet...

In the Breeders’ Cup Mile (G1), Deterministic turned the tables on Woodbine Mile (G1) conqueror Notable Speech to assure himself of the turf male championship. Earlier, Kathynmarissa cemented the turf female title in the Filly & Mare Turf (G1), which attracted a deep group of stars from across the Atlantic.

With a sensational, jaw-dropping rally in the Sprint (G1), T O Elvis landed the male sprint title over three-year-old Englishman, while Breeders’ Cup Saturday kicked off with Ways and Means clinching her female sprint title with a dominant display in the Filly & Mare Sprint (G1).

The Horse of the Year title likely goes to Sovereignty, too, despite the fact he won a mere two stakes all season. However, that would reemphasize how inconsistent the electorate at large is at enforcing their own arbitrary criteria. For example, the dominant argument against Arrogate in 2016 was that he hadn’t done enough to be named Horse of the Year, even though one of his two stakes wins had been an on-the-square defeat of eventual Horse of the Year California Chrome in the Classic.

Sovereignty's relatively thin record also highlights a worrying trend that spans many decades: today’s champions are generally far less accomplished than their ancestors.

If the horses noted above do end up winning their division titles, they will have won an average of 3.2 stakes this season. Ten years ago, in 2016, the average was 3.7. Earlier averages at 10-year intervals were 3.8 in 2006, 4.2 in 1996, 4.9 in 1986, 4.6 in 1976, and 5 in 1966.

The median number of stakes wins for presumptive flat champions in 2026 will be 3, the same number as in 2016. The median was 4 in 2006 and 1996, 5 in 1986 and 1976, and 4 in 1966.

Granted, all top-level horses are making fewer appearances, and thus stakes attempts, than they used to. Perhaps they’re winning a higher percentage of them now, too. 

At its highest level, the sport of racing and the breed itself have undoubtedly changed, and not necessarily for the better. 

FEATURED PRODUCTS

ADVERTISEMENT