Visit Our CDI Partners

Manhattan, Just a Game, Jaipur feature contentious fields

Last updated: 6/5/14 8:27 PM

Seek Again (right) nearly upset Wise Dan in the Woodford Reserve Turf Classic on Derby Day

(James Tyrrell/Horsephotos.com)

While dirt stars are very much in focus on Belmont Day, Saturday's

extravaganza at Belmont Park also features a trio of competitive turf stakes

that have attracted no shortage of contenders.

The Grade 1, $1 million

Manhattan Stakes, a 1 1/4-mile affair on the inner turf, serves as the

lead-in to California Chrome's bid for Triple Crown glory in the Belmont. Seek

Again, who came within a head of upsetting two-time Horse of the Year Wise Dan

in the Woodford Reserve Turf Classic on Kentucky Derby Day, will clash with the

respective top three from the May 11 Man o' War over this course -- Imagining,

Real Solution and Grandeur.

A Juddmonte Farms homebred, Seek Again was a progressive handicapper in

England for trainer John Gosden. The Speightstown colt made a smashing U.S., and

stakes, debut in last November's Hollywood Derby, where he slipped through on

the rail to a convincing 1 1/2-length decision. Remaining stateside and joining

Hall of Famer Bill Mott, Seek Again was not seen again until the Woodford

Reserve, forcing Wise Dan to find a bit extra to fend off his daring rally. Joel

Rosario retains the mount on the closer, who is drawn just about the middle of

the field in post 6.

"He seems to be coming into this race as good as he was going into the

(Woodford Reserve)," Mott said. "I thought he ran a winning race last time and

couldn't have been happier with his performance. I just hope his level of

fitness is the same and he feels like running (on Saturday)."

Imagining, the runner-up in the 2011 Hollywood Derby, is only now reaching

the peak of his powers for Hall of Fame trainer Shug McGaughey. A Phipps Stable

homebred like recent Manhattan winners Point of Entry (2013), Dancing Forever

(2008) and Good Reward (2005), Imagining has captured three of his last four.

The son of Giant's Causeway posted a front-running win in the October 17 Bowl

Game at this course and distance, rallied from off the pace in the November 16

Red Smith at Aqueduct, and opened 2014 with a closing second in the February 9

Gulfstream Park Turf. Imagining scored his Grade 1 breakthrough with a wire job

in the Man o' War, and hopes to double up here.

"He's doing great," McGaughey said. "He came out of his last race good and

has had two decent works since then.

"He won the Man o' War on a turf that had some give in it, but I think he's a

little better on (firm ground)."

The Man o' War trifecta of Imagining, Real Solution (left) and Grandeur (gray on inside) renew rivalry

(NYRA/Adam Coglianese Photography)

With Rosario on Seek Again, Imagining reverts to the services of Hall of

Famer John Velazquez for the first time since the Bowl Game. But he won't be the

controlling speed, for that distinction likely goes to Five Iron, who opened up

an insurmountable early lead to hold sway in the May 3 Fort Marcy last time out,

and will try to carry his speed an extra furlong here.

The Chad Brown-trained Real Solution is taking his second swing at the

Manhattan, having finished third to Point of Entry last year. But the son of

Kitten's Joy has a tendency of flattering only to fall short, and his lone

American victory came via the disqualification of The Apache in last summer's

Arlington Million. Real Solution again loomed menacingly in the Man o' War, but

was repelled by Imagining, and still has to prove his fighting qualities.

"Javier (Castellano) and I had made a decision to follow Amira's Prince (in

the Man o' War), and we probably focused too much on that," Brown said. "When

Amira's Prince didn't fire we got kind of stuck.

"He's coming into the race great," Brown added. "He drew the outside, which

is unfortunate, but hopefully we can work out a trip from there."

British shipper Grandeur kept on doggedly for third in the Man o' War in

circumstances that didn't play to his strengths. The combination of a better

pace scenario, firmer ground, first-time Lasix and a jockey switch to Hall of

Famer Gary Stevens could all conjure up improvement. The Jeremy Noseda charge

can take his game on the road, as illustrated by his American foray in the fall

of 2012, resulting in victories in the Hollywood Turf Cup and Twilight Derby and

a rattling second in the Hollywood Derby.

Seven-year-old millionaire Boisterous is the elder statesman of the field. An

erstwhile stablemate of Imagining's, he placed third in the 2012 Manhattan and

earned his Grade 1 laurel in last season's Man o' War. Boisterous was sold to

Gary Barber for $350,000 at Keeneland November and transferred from McGaughey to

Pletcher. Rounding into form for new connections, he got up for third to Wise

Dan and Seek Again in the Woodford Reserve last out, edging Kaigun.

Barber also has an ownership interest in Kaigun. Two starts back, Kaigun

trimmed Wise Dan's winning margin in the April 11 Maker's 46 Mile to

three-quarters of a length. Prior to that, the Mark Casse trainee wired a

February 22 Gulfstream Park allowance, beating Hey Leroy by 3 1/2 lengths. Hey

Leroy has since won the March 29 Appleton and took the runner-up spot in the May

17 Dixie at Pimlico, and now makes his 11th start of a hectic 2014 in the

Manhattan.

Chamois likewise exits the Dixie, where he forced the pace and held on

stubbornly for third in his reappearance. Trained by Christophe Clement, whose

trio of Manhattan winners includes Gio Ponti (2009) and Winchester (2010), the

stoutly-bred son of Smart Strike is entitled to move forward from that tightener.

"He's a nice horse, but I'm probably running him back a little quick, which I

don't like to do," Clement said. "He ran great the other day and it's a Grade 1,

so I thought we would take a shot."

A bright new face on the New York turf scene is Rookie Sensation, who looked

just that when rolling from off the pace in the November 1 Twilight Derby at

Santa Anita. Little has gone right for the John Shirreffs pupil since then.

Uncharacteristically on the early lead in the Hollywood Derby, he tired to fifth

behind Seek Again. In his latest venture in the April 25 Last Tycoon, the

Unbridled's Song colt was held up in traffic, got out too late, and settled for

a flying third to Quick Casablanca and Fire With Fire. Hall of Famer Mike Smith

will try to mastermind a cleaner trip this time.

Stephanie's Kitten (right) and Better Lucky, who staged a thrilling duel in the 2013 Just a Game, are back

(Jim Tyrrell/Horsephotos.com)

Two races earlier, Stephanie's Kitten mounts a title defense in the Grade 1,

$750,000

Just a

Game for turf distaffers over one mile on the Widener Turf. But the Kitten's

Joy mare comes off a subpar effort in the Jenny Wiley, her first outing for

Brown, and she must find herself in time to face a serious group of challengers

including Discreet Marq; Coffee Clique and Dame Marie, the top two from the

Churchill Distaff Turf Mile; the razor-sharp Somali Lemonade; her own stablemate

Waterway Run; and Better Lucky, who almost beat her here one year ago.

Stephanie's Kitten was a top-class performer for trainer Wayne Catalano,

racking up such significant trophies as the 2011 Breeders' Cup Juvenile Fillies

Turf and Alcibiades, 2012 Lake Placid and 2013 Churchill Distaff Turf Mile

before her hard-fought decision over Better Lucky in the Just a Game. Sidelined

after her fast-closing third in the July 27 Diana, the Ken and Sarah Ramsey

homebred was turned over to Brown in hopes of compiling an Eclipse-worthy season

in 2014. She returned to action in the April 12 Jenny Wiley at Keeneland, but

ran well below her best in eighth. Stephanie's Kitten might not just have needed

the race, considering that she had also run poorly in her only prior attempt

over the Keeneland turf. A change of scenery in this second start back could do

the trick, and Velazquez sticks with her.

Brown's other entrant, Waterway Run, was a Group 3 winner at Newmarket and a

creditable sixth in the 2012 Breeders' Cup Juvenile Fillies Turf when trained by

Ralph Beckett. The Arch filly was just denied in her first two tries for Brown

this year, in a Gulfstream allowance and in the March 8 Hillsborough at Tampa

Bay Downs, but got up to claim the May 3 Beaugay over the course.

Discreet Marq, who missed by all of a half-length in her Jenny Wiley

comeback, could be even happier on her home course. The Clement filly registered

three of her four stakes wins last season at Belmont -- the Pebbles at this

course and distance, the Eventail at 1 1/16 miles over the course and the Sands

Point on the inner. The captivating gray wasn't too bad in her two visits to

Southern California for Grade 1s either, landing the Del Mar Oaks and just

getting outdueled by Egg Drop in the Matriarch. Perhaps best at a flat mile, the

tactical daughter of Discreet Cat can monitor developments from post 9.

Discreet Marq is in better form since the Jenny Wiley, according to trainer Christophe Clement

(NYRA/Adam Coglianese Photography)

"She's a better horse today than when we ran in the Jenny Wiley," Clement

said. "She looked a little wintery, which she does not look now, and she's been

training very well. It's exciting."

Drawn widest of all in post 10 is Godolphin's Better Lucky, already a

two-time Grade 1 winner by virtue of her 2012 Matriarch and last October's First

Lady at Keeneland. A close third to Egg Drop and Discreet Marq in her Matriarch

title defense, the Tom Albertrani mare resumed in the April 12 Madison. That

seven-furlong sprint over Keeneland's Polytrack was better suited to 3-5

favorite Judy the Beauty, but Better Lucky closed smartly to finish best of the

rest, in an effort that should set her up well for Saturday.

"We think she's a horse whose best distance is between seven furlongs to a

mile," Albertrani said. "We wanted to try something different (in the Madison)

and we got exactly what we were looking for from her. We're looking for a good

effort from her in the Just a Game.

"She's won on firm and she's won on soft. She's very versatile, so I don't

think course condition will be an issue for her."

Coffee Clique and Somali Lemonade each bring two-race winning streaks into

the Just a Game. Although Coffee Clique looked better on synthetic than turf in

2013, the Brian Lynch filly has dispelled that notion this campaign. The

daughter of Medaglia d'Oro opened her four-year-old season successfully in a

Gulfstream turf allowance and followed up in the Distaff Turf Mile on Derby Day,

collaring Dame Marie in time. Dame Marie tries Coffee Clique again in the Just a

Game, along with Distaff Turf Mile fourth Ready Signal, who had earlier captured

a pair of minor turf stakes at Gulfstream.

Somali Lemonade has been rejuvenated with the application of blinkers.

Transformed into a front-running warrior, she has wired a Keeneland allowance

and the Gallorette on Preakness Day for Michael Matz. She'll probably have

Discreet Marq keep her honest here, though.

Maryland icon Ben's Cat ventures to Belmont for the Jaipur

(Jim McCue/Maryland Jockey Club)

"It sure looks like the blinkers have helped her out," Matz said. "I was

surprised she went to the front in the allowance race at Keeneland, but when it

works out, it's great. I'm just going with the flow."

"I don't know if this is too big of a step for her, but we wanted to try her

in a Grade 1 and the timing was good.

Strathnaver might want more ground, since her career high came in last year's

1 1/2-mile Bewitch at Keeneland, but the daughter of speedster Oasis Dream did

beat a tough opponent in Abaco in the 1 1/16-mile Lady Baltimore at Laurel in

September. From the ever-dangerous Graham Motion barn, Strathnaver warmed up for

this tilt with a fourth in the April 18 Doubledogdare over the Keeneland

Polytrack.

Rounding out the field is Unlimited Budget, the sixth-place finisher in the

2013 Belmont Stakes, who tries a turf experiment in hopes of kickstarting her

stalled career. At this time last year, the Todd Pletcher pupil ranked as one of

the nation's elite sophomore fillies. She won the first four starts of her

career by daylight, crowned by the Fair Grounds Oaks, and lost her unbeaten mark

when a fine third to Princess of Sylmar and Beholder in the Kentucky Oaks. But

Unlimited Budget has gone the wrong way in the interim, and checked in a

listless fifth in the La Troienne on Oaks Day. Not in good enough form for the

"clash of titans" in the Grade 1 Ogden Phipps, the Repole Stable colorbearer

took to the inner turf and fired a bullet half-mile in :47 4/5 Sunday, her first

recorded work on the surface, and gets Rosie Napravnik in the saddle.

The Grade 3, $300,000

Jaipur

Invitational has lured Ben's Cat from his usual Mid-Atlantic hunting

grounds, and the Maryland icon is eligible to push his career earnings past the

$2 million mark with anything like his usual effort in this six-furlong

inner-turf dash. Bred, owned and trained by the legendary King Leatherbury, the

venerable eight-year-old is riding a three-race winning skein. Ben's Cat capped

2013 with a repeat score in the Fabulous Strike on the dirt at Penn National,

and in his 2014 premiere, he won the Mister Diz, a five-furlong turf sprint at

Pimlico, for an amazing fifth straight year. When the Jim McKay Turf Sprint was

rained off the Pimlico turf May 16, it made no difference to Ben's Cat, who took

home the trophy for the third time in the last four years.

"He's an eight-year-old and he's come back as good as ever," said Leatherbury,

81, who plans to watch the Jaipur at Pimlico. "His first two races (this year)

were almost the exact same races he ran his first two races last year.

"Ben's Cat, he doesn't like to go to the front. He likes somebody to run at,

and I think he knows he's supposed to catch the horse in front of him. He never

wins by much, but he nails them when it's time to catch them."

Sporting a mark of 39-26-4-3, $1,967,990, Ben's Cat goes for his 22nd career

stakes victory, and regular rider Julian Pimentel comes along for the adventure.

Up-and-coming turf sprinter Marchman aims for his third consecutive Grade 3 score

(Rickelle Nelson/Horsephotos.com)

In contrast, four-year-old Marchman has just burst onto the radar as a turf

sprinter of note for Bret Calhoun. The winner of the April 12 Shakertown at

Keeneland and the Twin Spires Turf Sprint on Kentucky Oaks Day, the pace factor

looks for the hat trick in the Jaipur.

"He's a horse that's seemed to get better and better," Calhoun said. "We've

kept him sprinting on the grass his last two times, and I think he'll turf, dirt

or synthetic."

The Ben's Cat versus Marchman showdown might have taken place one week

earlier, in last Saturday's $150,000 Pennsylvania Governor's Cup at Penn

National, but both horsemen ended up switching to the Jaipur for twice the

purse.

"I originally was going to go to the Governor's Cup up there at Penn

National, but both (Leatherbury and I) changed our minds to go here," Calhoun

said. "I thought it was an obvious spot for him for more money. It's going to be

a good race."

"This race got a lot tougher," Leatherbury said. "Marchman is one and then

Linda Rice's horse (recent New York-bred stakes winner Marriedtothemusic) is

another. I thought I had the rest of them easily beat, but some of the

light-weighted horses at 114 pounds are contenders, too."

Positive Side has been chasing Marchman

in vain, coming up a neck shy in the 5 1/2-furlong Shakertown and settling for

third in the five-furlong Turf Sprint, and could be helped by the step up to six

panels. Another likely to enjoy a little more distance is Wes Welker's

consistent stakes-placer Undrafted, who split Marchman and Positive Side in the

Turf Sprint.

Other contenders include Upgrade, hero of the 2012 Jaipur and most recently

victorious in a local allowance for new trainer Chad Brown; perennial bridesmaid

Salto, who cuts back to the shortest race of his entire career in search of an

overdue first stakes win; and speedy Spring to the Sky, runner-up to Ben's Cat

in the 2013 Jim McKay.

"I've always been real high on this horse, but he's never been able to put it

together," trainer Bruce Brown said of Spring to the Sky. "He's one of those

horses that works fast in the morning and runs hard, so you have to space out

his races.

"We almost beat Ben's Cat -- well, we didn't almost beat him -- but we ran

good against him at Pimlico. Now he's coming to our home."

Bet Horseracing Free Online at TwinSpires.com

FEATURED PRODUCTS

ADVERTISEMENT